A colleague here at the library recently brought to my attention a post on the Boing Boing message board regarding libraries and intellectual property and, more specifically, about libraries' use of content controlled by Digital Rights Management (DRM) software. An organization called DefectiveByDesign.org is encouraging people to write their libraries to demand that they quit buying digital material from publishers who impose DRM technology on users.
It's intellectual property, it's digital, and, judging by the message board posting, it's got people riled up. It must be complicated, right?
It sure is! But it's also interesting, if you're into this sort of thing.
DRM technology is a blanket term used to describe any software that restricts the use of something that is sold digitally but still protected by copyright.
Wonder why you can't burn a million copies of your mix CD that you made with songs you bought from iTunes? That would be DRM.
Remember the scandal that erupted a couple of years ago when Sony encrypted music CDs with some piracy-prevention software that made people's computers susceptible to viruses? Another form of DRM.
If you've ever tried to read or listen to an eBook or watch digital content from one of the major vendors that the library buys from, you have also experienced DRM. These companies generally require that you use their proprietary reader to view the book. This is so that they can restrict the amount of pages you can print, the amount of copies you can make, etc, and prevent people from illegally copying the works.
If you read the whole complaint from the anti-DRM crew, you'll find that their primary complaint is not about the clunkiness of these interfaces (having worked in libraries, I suppose I could furnish a few complaints if you want me to), but rather about the need to use certain software to access the digital material you borrow from the library. For instance, to read an eBook, you may need to have Internet Explorer. To listen to a digital audiobook, you may have to have Windows Media Player. If you want to watch streaming video content, you may have to have Windows Vista. Not all vendors have the same software requirements, but the argument seems to be that enough do that it has an effect on the software market -- if enough library users are using digital material that requires them to favor a certain brand of computer products, there is an adverse effect on the other software producers.
The companies that attach these restrictions to their materials are not doing anything illegal. What they are doing is using a contract to prevent libraries from exercising rights that they would otherwise have. Libraries have enjoyed a fair amount of wiggle room in our application of copyright law. By building restrictions into licensing contracts, the publishers are preventing what has been standard practice for decades, or at least as long as photocopiers have been around.
The professional organization that represents librarians, the ALA, recommends a compromise in the form of updated guidelines for DRM. What do you think? Is it fair for companies to exercise this level of control over their intellectual property?
Carrie Russell has written an indispensable copyright reference for librarians called Complete Copyright: An Everyday Guide for Librarians. No DRM concerns for this book; we only have it in print.
Wednesday, May 14, 2008
Copyright, Digital Rights Management (DRM), and Libraries
Tuesday, May 6, 2008
Shoe Company Discovers That Infringement Can Be Expensive
A discount shoe company lost some big money because of their use of what a Portland court determined to be a protected mark this week.
As soccer players and fans of old school rap already knew, Adidas uses three more or less vertical stripes to represent their products. Collective Brands, Inc., makers of Payless and Stride Rite learned that the hard ($305 million) way.
Read more about the case here.
Companies sue each other all the time, but it's interesting to me that these three lines cost Collective Brands so many millions of dollars. How can somebody register something as simple as a geographic figure?
Trademark law covers much more than words and pictures. Essentially, anything that helps consumers identify a specific service or product is protected. Stephen Elias talks about it in his excellent Trademark: Legal Care for Your Business & Product Name (available at SFPL):
"...[I]t's not just a clever business or product name that pulls in the customers. Equally important in the vast U.S. consumer marketplace are the logos, packaging, innovative product shapes, cartoon characters, website address names (domain names), and unique product characteristics that businesses are using to hawk their wares."
Something as simple as a big yellow "M," a big brown truck, or pink fiberglass insulation can qualify. A mark, unlike a patent or a copyright, doesn't have to be unique to the world; it simply has to be unique as a marketing device for a particular product or service.
I'm going to assume that Collective Brands, Inc., didn't innocently use the vertical stripes, that it never occurred to their designers that the design resembled Adidas'. Trademarks exist so that consumers can reliably identify goods and services from certain providers, so it seems like a legit ruling to me. Anybody else?
Wednesday, April 16, 2008
Harry Potter and the Fair Use Litigation
There's a lawsuit brewing around Harry Potter intellectual property rights, and this time it's not a rock band suing Jarvis Cocker and members of Radiohead over band-naming rights.
This time the lawsuit centers on a vague but important clause of U.S. Copyright Code known as "fair use:"
Notwithstanding the provisions of sections 106 and 106A, the fair use of a copyrighted work, including such use by reproduction in copies or phonorecords or by any other means specified by that section, for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching (including multiple copies for classroom use), scholarship, or research, is not an infringement of copyright. In determining whether the use made of a work in any particular case is a fair use the factors to be considered shall include—(1) the purpose and character of the use, including whether such use is of a commercial nature or is for nonprofit educational purposes;(3) the amount and substantiality of the portion used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole; andThe fact that a work is unpublished shall not itself bar a finding of fair use if such finding is made upon consideration of all the above factors. from 17 USC s.107
Fair use is the reason why book reviewers can include quotes from sources they are critiquing, the reason teachers can hand out photocopies of sections of a published work to students, and why a student can use a chart from a published study in a research paper for school.
One of the historic problems with fair use is that it requires interpretation on the part of the person using a copyrighted work. Since copyright owners may not want to grant permissions, or may want to charge exorbitant fees, artists may take a gamble and use works without permission. If a suit is brought against the artist, the courts will determine if their use was fair or not; in the mean time, it's better than asking and being rejected.
The defense in the Harry Potter case are likely to argue that their use of Rowlings' ideas constitutes fair use as both work of literary criticism and as a transformative work, uses that are often considered fair.
Attorneys from Stanford Law School are defending this case. The outcome could have a major effect on the way copyright is interpreted in the future. I'll keep my eye on it.
In the mean time, for more information about copyright and fair use check out:
Fair Use, Free Use, and Use by Permission Lee Wilson. New York: Allworth Press, 2005. Available at SFPL.
Creative Commons
U.S. Copyright Office
Saturday, March 22, 2008
Wouldn't it be nice...
...if the remaining founders of the Beach Boys could share their intellectual property? According to the New York Times, that may soon be the case as they have reportedly settled a series of litigation over alleged misuse of the Beach Boys name.
The Beach Boys trademark is registered to Brother Records, Inc., the group's corporate entity. The dispute was reportedly about the use of the name by Al Jardin, a founder of the group and a shareholder in Brother Records, Inc.
For most musicians, copyright is the only intellectual property issue they'll ever have to deal with. The Beach Boys brand, however, is so recognizable that it can command some large sums, in this case in the millions.
The Beach Boys saga is a fascinating one that goes way beyond intellectual property. You can read all about it at SFPL.
Friday, March 14, 2008
The Guitar Hero Patent Scandal
Reuters (and a couple dozen other news sources) reports here that Gibson Guitar is suing Activision, claiming that Activision's popular Guitar Hero video game infringes Gibson's 1999 patent number 5990405 for "System and Method for Generating and Controlling a Simulated Music Concert."
See Gibson's patent here.
See the Guitar Hero patent here.
This is a good illustration of how patents are enforced. The USPTO does not take any action to enforce patents once they are granted. It's up to a patent holder to pursue perceived infringement through courts, like Gibson is doing right now.
Also, if you take a look at the patents, you can see that infringement isn't always cut and dry. Do you think Gibson has a good case?
Tuesday, March 11, 2008
Patent Circuit Court to Appear Locally
If you were planning a trip to Washington, D.C. to watch the Patent Court of Appeals in action, you can save your money.
CNET's BLIP blog reported that the Court is taking their act on the road, appearing in San Francisco and San Jose courts and Stanford and Santa Clara law schools in November.
Click here for the official press release.
Sunday, March 9, 2008
Intellectual Property Bill Passes House Subcommittee
Variety reported last week that the House IP Subcommittee passed the Prioritizing Resources and Organization for Intellectual Property Act . The bill calls for expanding anitpiracy efforts with the creation of an Executive coordinator of antipiracy efforts, offering grant money to states, and stiffer fines for willful intellectual property offenses.
This is, of course, only one step on a bill's journey to becoming a law. Click here for a good explanation of the legislative process.
A good primer on IP law is "Patent, Copyright, and Trademark: An Intellectual Property Desk Reference," by Rich Stim, published by Nolo. Click here for an electronic version of the 2006 edition (library card required). We also have the 2007 edition in paper at the Government Information Center Reference Desk.
