Saturday, December 20, 2008

You know you're big when someone tries to trademark your name

And now, the latest news from the intellectual property in sports desk: NFL quarterback Vince Young is suing three individuals who have tried to register his nicknames, "VY" and "Invinceable," with the USPTO. According to USA Today, Young's lawyer has said that the trademark registration has stood in the way of a deal with Reebok, who was apparently interested in marketing some "VY" merchandise.

I checked it out on TESS and, sure enough, the mark is currently registered. (To see for yourself, go to the uspto.gov website, click on trademarks on the left side, and then click on TESS, the third option down. Enter the mark in the "New User Form Search.")

For an enlightening discussion of the ins and outs of using personal names as trademarks, check out the latest edition of Stephen Elias and Richard Stim's Trademark: Legal Care for your Business & Product Name. (That link is to the eBook, which requires a library card to log in. If you don't have one and you're a California resident, you're in luck: SFPL has a brand-new eCard, which gives CA residents access to thousands of online resources. Learn more about it here.)

Trademark woes aside, it must be quite an ego-booster when somebody feels that your name or nickname is valuable enough to merit a trademark registration!

Friday, December 19, 2008

Take it from the agency -- 3 great free publications from the USPTO and the Copyright Office

The way that laws and regulations is written is extremely important. If the wording is imprecise, enterprising people find loopholes and, before you know it, the intent of the law is undermined. Our Federal goverment has a couple of hundred years' experience creating the kind of air-tight prose that holds up to scrutiny, and while this kind of language is important for those interested in the law, it's almost always incomprehensible for those poor folks (call them laypeople) who have to try to do some kind of business with the government.

The commercial publishing industry certainly has picked up on the market for people who want help dealing with the government, and many of the millions of people each year who want to apply for a patent or register a trademark or copyright get some help using titles from NOLO Press, Sphinx, Oceana, and other publishers.

It's worth noting that, in addition to commercially produced guides to intellectual property, the agencies themselves (in this case the USPTO and the US Copyright Office) have done an excellent job of creating materials to educate the public about these areas of law. Although commercial publishers have the advantage of being able to offer subjective legal advice to readers, the agencies themselves are the most authoritative source for information about intellectual property. Below are just three examples of publications that I find particularly useful:

Copyright Circular 1: Copyright Basics
United States Copyright Office

There are some people who need lots of detailed information about copyright in the U.S. Attorneys, for instance. Or artists who plan to use someone else's work or prevent someone else from using their work. Recording industry executives seem pretty interested in our copyright law, as do some Members of Congress. For these folks, there are mountains of materials, published by commercial, academic, and government presses, covering laws, legislation, case history, trends, etc. in the field of copyright.

For the rest of us, there's a wonderfully concise series of publications, called Circulars, that come to us courtesy of the U.S. Copyright Office. There are a couple dozen of these things, covering pretty much every matter of business most folks will ever have with the Copyright Office. I'm not promising a riveting read (example: Circular 4oA, Deposit Requirements for Registration of Claims to Copyright in Visual Arts Material). I do think, however, that in an information environment rife with misinformation (I'm referring to the Internet), it's extremely important to have reliable, authoritative information about legal topics. Copyright Circular 1 is just that. It's readable, informative, comprehensive, and pretty darn concise considering the breadth of the subject matter that it covers. This is an excellent place to begin any copyright research.

A Guide to Filing a Utility Patent Application
US Patent and Trademark Office

David Pressman's Patent it Yourself is probably our most popular guide to filing a utility patent. One of the major selling points of the book is Pressman's direct, no-frills writing style. It's a testament to the complexity of the patent system, then, that such a concise writer still requires 572 pages (in the latest edition) to demonstrate how to get a patent.

A Guide to Filing a Utility Patent Application, the USPTO's consumer patent application pamphlet, is 16 pages long and is, arguably, as indispensable for fledgling patentees as Pressman's book. How? It's written in haiku (not true). The pamphlet is actually short simply because it contains a lot less information than Pressman's book does. It is, however, still very useful because it contains the very basic facts about what patent examiners expect from a utility patent application in one short, direct, and authoritative volume.

Think of it this way: Will the Periodical Table of the Elements tell a layperson everything about chemistry? Of course not. But, when used alongside other, more expository texts, it is an essential reference in that field. Same goes with A Guide to Filing a Utility Patent Application. Here at the library, we keep copies on hand for quick reference.

(By the way, if you want to know everything there is to know about U.S. patent prosecution, I refer you to the Manual of Patent Examining Procedure, all four inches (thickness, that is) of small print and tissue-thin paper.)


Basic Facts About Trademarks
US Patent and Trademark Office

There are few trademark questions that come across our reference desk that have an answer that cannot be found in the USPTO's Basic Facts About Trademarks. Should I register my mark? Page 1! How do I submit a colored drawing? Page 6! How long does my registration last? Page 14! There's even a current International Schedule of Goods and Services on pages 16-17. Basic Facts does for trademark researchers what A Guide to Filing a Utility Patent Application does for wannabe patentees; that is, it acts as a starting point, an unassuming collection of the facts essential to a basic understanding of the trademark process.

The USPTO did us all a favor by adopting a question-and-answer format for this brochure, and that, to me, is what makes it stand out among trademark informational brochures, of which there are many. Most of us who are using trademark informational brochures don't know the first thing about trademarks. Though we may have a specific question that brings us to the brochure, we may notice another question that we didn't even know we had. Intent to use? Tell me more! Also handy is the "trademark, patent, or copyright?" segment at the very beginning of the brochure, which can save the true new-comer the trouble of exploring the wrong avenues of intellectual property.

There's much more available from the agencies that you can access for free by visiting the USPTO and Copyright Office websites, or by stopping in to see us at the public library.

Friday, December 12, 2008

Update: Another piece of the trademark search puzzle, available here at the library

Update, 8/25: Trademarkscan was many things to many people, but one thing that it wasn't, at least at the San Francisco Public Library, was popular. I'm sorry to report that TMScan is no longer available at the Patent and Trademark Center. Please get in touch if you're interested in learning about alternative approaches to state TM searching.

Original post:
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A proper trademark search can be quite a puzzle, particularly because there is no one central place to find the information. Though there is a Federal trademark registry that's pretty easy to work with, the USPTO does not have a monopoly on trademark registrations. As I've mentioned in a previous post (and as I'm realizing I should write about in more depth in the future), a mark doesn't necessarily have to be registered with the USPTO to be enforceable. Remember, the purpose of a trademark is to help consumers identify products and services. It follows, then, that a longstanding mark associated with a particular enterprise may have some protection, regardless of registration status.

What's best for consumers isn't necessarily good for trademark searchers, however. To research a mark that's intended for use across the country, a Federal trademark search is a good start, but there are a couple of other elements that a completist searcher will want to consult. The first, a common law trademark search, can be done using a few resources that the Business, Science, and Technology department here at the library has. You can read about that here.

Another component of the search process is finding marks registered in individual states. Many businesses only operate within a particular state, and in those cases, registration within that state may be sufficient. A trademark registration in a particular state may interfere with use of the mark within that state, so it's wise to check state trademark registries as part of a trademark search. You can check each state individually -- to search California trademarks, for instance, visit the Secretary of State's website -- but, for those able to come into the library, we have a tool that allows one-stop shopping for state trademark registrations. It's called Trademarkscan, and it's a for-pay database that you can use for free at the library. Using Trademarkscan, you can perform a search across all fifty states of registered trademarks. If you have a mark that you think that you may want to use in several states, this could be a real timesaver for you.

Wednesday, November 26, 2008

"Gobble up some of these a-maize-ing patents and trademarks"

For your Thanksgiving enjoyment, I refer you to the USPTO's Kid's Pages to feast (I love puns as much as the USPTO does) on some patents and trademarks from their files.

Most of the patents are turkey-related, though a few, like this gravy separator, are ostensibly vegetarian-friendly.

While you're there, take a look at some of the other features in the Kid's Pages. If you have kids, work with kids, or are a kid, you may find yourself thankful that the Department of Commerce put so much into these pages.

Tuesday, November 18, 2008

USPTO Annual Report for FY 2008 shows record

The USPTO released their annual report for FY 2008 yesterday, and boy was it a doozy. Here are some highlights from their press release:

Patents – Optimizing Patent Quality and Timeliness

In FY 2008, USPTO met and, in some cases, exceeded its patent pendency, production, and quality targets. Patents maintained a high level of patent quality by achieving an allowance compliance rate of 96.3 percent, exceeding its goal.

  • Patents increased production by an additional 14 percent over FY 2007 by examining 448,003 applications—the highest number in history. Production has increased by 38.6 percent over the past four years, compared to a 21.3 percent increase in application filings during the same period.
  • Patents received a record number of utility patent applications filed electronically (332,617), and achieved a record rate (72.1 percent) of applications filed electronically as well.
  • Patents achieved an average first action pendency of 25.6 months and an average total pendency of 32.2 months.
  • Patents received 1,765 patent application filings through the Accelerated Examination Program, 173 percent more than in the program’s introductory year of FY 2007. A 12-month or less pendency rate was also maintained for every application, with an average time to final action or allowance of 186 days.

Trademarks – Optimizing Trademark Quality and Timeliness

For the third year in a row, USPTO met or exceeded all of its performance goals for trademarks as well.

  • Trademarks ended its year with first action pendency at three months. Trademarks has maintained its first action pendency within the 2.5 to 3.5 month range for more than 18 months, a historic first. Disposal pendency was also maintained at record low levels, ending the year with 11.8 months pendency for cases without inter partes or suspended cases and at 13.9 months for all disposals. This disposal pendency is the lowest in 20 years.
  • This year saw a record number of applications filed electronically--approximately 268,000 applications comprising 390,000 classes. This represented a record rate of filing; 96.9 percent of all applications were filed electronically.
  • Quality remained high throughout the year with a first action compliance rate of 95.8 percent and a final action compliance rate of 97.2 percent. Both measures exceeded performance expectations.


That's right, '08 saw records in both patent applications and electronic trademark applications.

View the full report here.

Thursday, November 13, 2008

Trademarks:Some tips for searching for images at the USPTO

Based on my experience helping people at our reference desk, I would argue that images are perhaps the greatest source of confusion for fledgling trademark searchers. I suspect that this is because the predominant 21st Century searching habit -- namely, keyword searching -- relies on matching words directly rather than filtering words through an index. Given the amount of information available through the Internet, keyword searching works just fine to call up text-based resources, but it really falls short when it comes to non-text information like pictures. Image searching through popular search engines is OK when you quickly need a picture of, say, an ostrich pulling a cart, but for a legal need like a trademark search, when a business' identity (not to mention a lot of money!) is at stake, something more reliable is necessary.

Anyone familiar with the United States Patent Classification understands just how seriously the USPTO takes their indexing. And for the same reasons patent searchers must take the time to learn the USPC, a person eager to perform a comprehensive trademark search at the USPTO would do well to learn how to use the trademark Design Search Code Manual.

Every trademark that is based on an image is assigned a Design Code (DC) at the time of registration. Once registered, those marks are available through the Trademark Electronic Search System (TESS) and are searchable through that DC that an examiner assigned. To find marks containing a specific image, a searcher can find the corresponding DC number using an online version of the Design Search Code Manual (sorry, no acronym for this one).

That's a mouthful, I know, but it's really more simple than it sounds. The idea is that you can look up words that describe what your image is, match those words to the appropriate DC number, then look up that number in the trademark database to inspect other marks that have that DC number.

Let's say, for example, that I have a line of gardening gloves. I call them Moose Gloves and I've had a gifted artist create this logo as my brand:
Before I register my new trademark, I want to make sure that nobody else has registered a mark in the same class of goods that resembles my mark.

Using TESS, I can search for the words that I plan to use in my mark, but I also want to make sure that I catch any similar images before I send the application. To do this, I'll consult the Design Search Code Manual. Under "M," I scroll down until I see moose (that's what the drawing is, by the way). The Manual tells me that the DC number for moose is 03.07.07.

If you're not entirely sure that a DC number adequately describes your image, you can click on the number to get examples. I should also mention that the Manual is pretty comprehensive and includes codes for geometric shapes, celestial bodies, mythological figures, ethnic groups -- if you can imagine the variety of trademarked images you've encountered in your life, just think that there's a DC number assigned to each.

To continue with our example, now that I have a DC number for my moose, I can go to TESS, choose the "structured form search," then enter the number (without punctuation, so my moose would be "030707"). In the drop-down menu in the field box, choose Design Code. If you want to narrow the results of the search, you can also enter a US class number in the second search box. (Class numbers are found using the Trademark Acceptable Identification of Goods and Services manual, which you can access online here.) If you do enter a search term in the second box, make sure to change the operator, on the right side of the screen, from "or" to "and."

When you click search, this will bring up a list of all, if any, registered marks that match your search. To browse the images that came up from your search, look for a blue button at the top of the screen that says "image list." Clicking this will bring up just the images in a way that makes it easy to scroll through and look at your search results.

None of the artwork that came up from my search were of the same caliber as my moose, so it looks like I'm safe. Remember that, as always, the idea is to have a mark that is not confusingly similar to another mark in the same class. Happy hunting!

Sunday, November 9, 2008

New in the Patent and Trademark Center -- Gifts for the inventor in your life

The latest issue of Inventor's Digest has arrived at the Patent and Trademark Center. Just in time for the holiday season, this month's issue has a feature about gifts for inventors. They make a compelling argument for the importance of having a benchtop injection molder (make your own prototypes). They also review some books, games, software, and other fun stuff like the Magical Thinking Hat, which I like to imagine every patent examiner wearing while they examine applications.

The magazine is currently on display in the Patent and Trademark Center at the Main Library.