As usual, I scooped the Wall Street Journal by a few months with my report on the Congressional trademark protection given to the Olympics Committee. In all fairness, their story is, er, better, and thus perhaps worth a click.
Friday, August 1, 2008
Sunday, July 27, 2008
"My invention consists in the arrangement of two wheels, the one directly in front of the other..."
I can't think of any technological advancement more simple, elegant, and useful than the bicycle. With all of the bicycle-related-events going on this summer abroad and here in San Francisco, including a film series here at the Main Library, it's nice to see that people aren't taking the two-wheeler for granted after well over a century of popular use. This led me to wonder where the bicycle came from.
The history of technology is dotted with examples of spontaneous inventions, of people plucking inspiration from the sky and inventing something entirely new. In 1849, when New Yorker Walter Hunt needed $15 to repay a debt to a friend, he took a length of wire, invented the safety pin, and sold the rights for $400.
That doesn't happen very often. Like most lasting innovations, the development of bicycles involved a series of gradual improvements upon previous designs. The earliest vehicle that a modern person might recognize as a precursor to the bicycle is Karl von Drais' draisienne. This early 19th century two-wheeler looks remarkably close to a modern bicycle, especially considering some of the stylistic diversions later two-wheelers would take. Have a look:
Not bad for a first try, right? There are, however, a couple of things about this design that prevented it from starting a transportation revolution; most notably, perhaps, is the lack of pedals or a chain. The vehicle is propelled using Flintstone-era drive train technology.
In the 1860's, the solution to the problem of locomotion began to pop up in France in the form of pedals. At first, pedals were attached directly to the bicycle's wheel, like you see in the patent drawing below, from Pierre Lallement's 1866 "Improvement in Velocipedes:"
This design (the French called it a velocipede) represents a major step forward, but attaching the pedals directly to the front wheel meant that the bicycle was still going to be, well, rather slow. If you ever rode one of those little red tricycles as a kid, then you're familiar with this configuration -- for every turn of the pedal, you get one turn of the wheel. That means that for each stroke, the vehicle only moves the length of the circumference of the wheel, which is really tiny in the case of a little red tricycle and still small enough to inhibit fast cycling in the early velocipedes.
Although the chain transmission was around by the 1870's, the prevailing solution to the problem of the 1:1 pedal to wheel revolution ratio was to make bigger wheels which traveled a greater distance for each revolution. Thus, the "penny-farthing:"The big-wheel solution proved temporary as the metallurgical technology would catch up within the next couple of decades to enable chains and steering mechanisms, both of which pretty closely resemble the components of a modern bicycle.
There was, however, one missing component that prevented the bicycle from transcending the status of amusement device to become a revolutionary means of transportation -- a comfortable ride. Early bicycles were called "bone-shakers," which gives you an idea of how people felt about riding on either solid wheels or wheels with solid rubber tires over dirt and cobblestone roads. A Scottish man named John Dunlop (last name bring anything to mind?) figured out that if he equipped his son's tricycle, the kid wouldn't get headaches from the bumpy ride. He patented pneumatic tires in 1888, and shortly began to manufacture modern tires with inner tubes. And the rest is history.
The development is a testament to the collaborative nature of technological advancement, the idea that we arrive at groundbreaking technologies like the bicycle by building on the advancements of others. There is no one bicycle patent; the bicycles that carry people to work and play are the result of hundreds of patents for gears, inner tubes, levers, ball bearings, and every other component.
We've got a pretty nice collection of books about the history of inventions, including fun titles by Umberto Eco and Tom Philbin that proved very helpful in writing this post.
Wednesday, July 23, 2008
Yeah, what he said...
Fellow patent librarian Michael White posted on his blog, The Patent Librarian's Notebook, a piece about the importance of class and subclass searching that very succinctly illustrates that, regardless of the type of invention, keyword searching won't suffice for a prior art search. I highly recommend it.
Saturday, July 12, 2008
It's All About the Bar Codes at the New Electronic Copyright Office
A couple months back, I noticed that the U.S. Copyright Office was testing online registration for basic forms. At the time, I had no idea how serious those copyright folks were about using technology to streamline the copyright registration process.
As of July 1st, forms TX (literary works), VA (visual arts), PA (performing arts), SR (sound recordings), and SE (single serials) are no longer available for download on the Copyright Office's website, which tells me that they are pushing the electronic registration system (online registration and a new super-form, discussed below) as the primary method for registration.
What does this mean for copyright registrants? Ever the amateur analyst, I've devised three categories of copyright registrants and their options for registration.
For early adapters who wish to file a basic claim
To register many of the most common types of works, users can now go completely digital using the eCO system I mentioned in a previous post. The works that qualify for the online system are those featuring what are called basic claims, meaning "literary works, visual arts works, performing arts works, sound recordings, motion pictures, and single serial issues." You know, the artsy stuff.
I suspect that one of the reasons the Copyright Office is only now rolling out online registration is that they had to figure out a way to meet the deposit requirement. Title 17 of U.S. Code, the law that establishes U.S. copyright, requires a copyright owner to hand over copies of a published work to the Library of Congress. This requirement has worked its way into the Copyright Office's policies to include any work to be registered, published or not.
Deposit of a hard copy is still required for most works, but it is still recommended that registrants file their claims online. During the online filing process, the system will generate a shipping label that the registrant can attach to the package that they will use to mail their deposit.
For some types of works, including unpublished works and electronic-only works, an online deposit is sufficient. In either case, the fees are reduced to $35 to reflect the reduction in man-hours required to process registrations.
For those who respect the efficiency of the computer-based application but still consider the tactile experience essential to registering copyright
The Copyright Office has developed a new form, called form CO, that can be used to register literary works, performing arts works, visual arts works, motion picture works, audiovisual works, sound recording, and single serial issues.
This new super-form generates bar codes as you type, which means that an application can be read by a machine for faster processing. I tried one out and was very amused. Using this method to file still costs $45, but I'm guessing it will greatly speed up the registration process, plus it takes the guess work out of choosing a form. Form CO can be used in place of forms TX, VA, PA, SR, and SE, and is the only form currently available for download at the Copyright Office website.
For the traditionalists
If you aren't ready to give up filing by hand, you don't have to worry yet: you can still get the forms, though you can no longer download them directly from the Copyright Office's website. If you fill out the electronic form linked above, they'll send you copies of the forms. We'll also keep the forms in stock here at the Government Information Center for as long as they'll keep sending them to us. There are still several types of works that must be registered using the paper forms, so logic tells me that the forms will be around for at least as long as that requirement is in place. The cost for paper registration will remain $45.
If you're still a little fuzzy about registration, check out the classic Copyright Office Circular Number 1, "Copyright Basics." As always, please feel free to get in touch with us at the Government Information Center if you'd like help figuring out your registration needs.
Saturday, July 5, 2008
Dubious Inventor Resources #1, or, Dr. Phil and the Overestimation of the Power of the Provisional Patent Application
Syndicated television talk show host Phil McGraw, aka Dr. Phil, has made a career of pushing the boundaries of psychotherapy to include finances, dieting, and, now, intellectual property.
It just came to my attention that the good doctor has published an article on his website offering his unique brand of no-nonsense advice to inventors. Phil, who "worked in litigation for years and has experience with patents and intellectual property," also calls on his buddy A.J. Khubani, a big-time infomercial producer, to weigh in on the subject.
The bulk of the advice is solid, if a little obvious, truisms such as "make a business plan," " do market research," "be patient," and the like. The kind of advice that we can all agree on -- except for one little piece of advice from Mr. Khubani that strikes me as a little misleading and potentially damaging for fledgling inventors:
“Patents are the best way to protect your idea, but they take a lot of money,” A.J. explains, noting that a patent can cost $10-30,000. “The smarter way to do it is go online — USPTO.gov — and file for a provisional patent. It cost $105, and that’s it. You’ve protected your idea.”I'm not actually interested in (read "qualified for") nitpicking all of the advice on the internet that pertains to intellectual property, but this one -- and I suspect it may have been taken out of context -- caught my eye because it reflects a potentially confusing part of the patent process that may be worth talking about a little bit here.
The problem that I see in Khubani's advice is that there is no distinction made between full patent applications and provisional patent applications, which is like making no distinction between appetizers and the main course.
Provisional patents are a relatively new addition to the inventor's arsenal, and they exist as a cheap and relatively easy way to establish the date of an invention and to tentatively protect the invention while the inventor evaluates its commercial potential. An inventor sends in a description of an invention, drawings if they're necessary to explain the invention -- and these don't have to be done to the same strict specs that full patent drawings have -- and a hundred bucks. The inventor then has a year to build a prototype, perform market research (like Dr. Phil said), try to sell the invention, and then, if all of that pans out, go to the trouble and expense of filing a full patent application.
In the old days (before provisional patent applications were given the green light in 1995) there were two ways to prove when something was invented: the inventor could either create and document the creation, with witness and all, of working prototype, or file a full patent. Neither of these options is particularly fast, nor easy to do on the cheap. Provisional patents enable inventors to take a year to evaluate their invention, and in the mean time, they can claim "patent pending" status on their invention. (Without the provisional patent application, it's illegal to do that.) If the inventor doesn't file a full patent application within a year, the provisional patent application expires, and the protection effectively ends.
And so we arrive at the point of this post -- filing a provision is not "it." For a successful invention, the provisional application is only the very beginning.
Dr. Phil seems, for the most part, to advocate a cautious approach to patenting. The provisional patent application as a first step fits nicely into this approach.
You may want to check out a couple of books that we have here at the library if you're interested in protecting an invention. Not that I think Dr. Phil is overstepping his area of expertise. Hey, if David Pressman wrote a self-help book, I'd probably buy it for the collection.
Monday, June 30, 2008
The Foundation of the U.S. Patent System
Inscribed above the front door of the Department of Commerce building in Washington, D.C. is a quote from Abraham Lincoln that neatly sums up the role that patents have played in developing the industry and commerce that have come to define the United States as we know it:
THE PATENT SYSTEM ADDED THE FUEL OF INTEREST TO THE FIRE OF GENIUS
Patents have been with us almost since the United States' inception and have acted, as Lincoln eloquently points out, as an incentive to innovate. It may be useful, then, to pause between bites of hot dog and fireworks shows this Independence Day to take a look at the genesis of the patent system in the U.S.
The power of Congress to establish a limited monopoly for inventors was laid out in Article I, Section 8 of the Constitution:
To promote the progress of science and useful arts, by securing for limited times to authors and inventors the exclusive right to their respective writings and discoveries;When George Washington signed the Patent Act of April 14, 1790, the burden of examining patent applications landed on a three person panel consisting of the Secretary of State, Secretary of War, and the Attorney General.
The first patent was granted July 31, 1790, to Samuel Hopkins of Philadelphia. Though the handwritten document looks pretty primitive compared to a modern patent, you can see the basic elements are there: a description of the invention (it was a new method for making something called pot ash, a material in the soap-making process), an affirmation that it was new and useful, and the granting to the exclusive right to use and sell the invention to the inventor and his heirs for a specified term (14 years at the time).
Try to imagine Condaleeza Rice, Michael Mukasey, and Robert Gates scheduling time every day to examine patents. After three years, Thomas Jefferson, Henry Knox, and Edmund Randolph found that examining applications and mediating interferences (when two people apply for the same or similar patents at around the same time) took up too much of their time. In 1793, Congress passed a revised patent law with a much more lenient process in which patents were registered without being examined.
It wasn't until the Act of July 4, 1836 that examination was restored. This act more or less established the modern patent system, in which the Commissioner of Patents, who was appointed by the President with Senate confirmation, led an office of examiners who would determine the usefulness and novelty of an invention. 1836 is also the year that patents were first numbered; the older patents have an "X" before their numbers, which were assigned retroactively.
There are some pretty great stories from the early days of the Patent Office, like where William Thornton, an early Superintendent, laid such a guilt-trip on the British soldiers burning Washington D.C. in 1814 that they spared the building in which the patent models were stored.
For those with any interest in the history of patents in the U.S., we have a couple of books here at the Patent and Trademark Center. (We also have a full run of U.S. patents, which itself is an astounding historical document.)
When you're lighting your hand-protector-equipped sparkler at your Independence Day celebration this year, don't forget the role that inventors played in the early years of the United States.
Wednesday, June 18, 2008
Patents -- Where are the forms, and how much does it cost?
If you've ever done business with any government entity in the U.S., you've probably learned very quickly how things tend to go. In my experience, there are two components that define a transaction with any office affiliated with any government -- a form or several forms, and a nominal fee.
Need a dog license? Owe taxes? Want a passport? Fill out the paperwork, cut a check, and be on your way.
It follows, then, that I, as a sort of go-between for people and the USPTO, am very frequently asked where the forms for patents can be found and how much it costs to apply for a patent.
The forms are simple enough to find: we have or can get copies of all of the forms for photocopying here at the library, and all of the forms are available for download from the UPSTO website. It's important to remember, though, that filing a patent application involves much more than filling out a couple of forms. To quote the USPTO brochure A Guide to Filing a Utility Patent Application, "a patent application is a complex legal document." Click on the link to that brochure to get an idea of the parts of a complete utility patent application.
Estimating the cost of filing can be a little more complicated. Since no two patent applications are the same, the USPTO has created a sort of patent application menu, with different costs associated with different parts of the application.
To help you figure out how much you need pay, one of the forms that applicants need to fill out, called a Fee Transmittal, is a sort of checklist that you can match to the fee schedule (the official name for the menu referred to above).
If you take a look at the Fee Transmittal, it kind of resembles an income tax return -- you fill in certain values on certain lines, add or multiply other values depending on your application, then enter new values on new lines with new variables with the goal of arriving at a specific amount which you owe. (Unlike tax returns, you will always owe something.)
Also like your taxes, it's very important that you take the time to calculate your fees, check your calculations, then maybe check them again before sending in your application. If you make a mistake and send too little, you may have to pay a surcharge and your application prosecution may be delayed.
All of the above really only gives a taste of the process of applying for a patent, but my goal here, as at the reference desk, is to help people gather all of the information and materials necessary to start the process. I suspect that to many novice inventors, it comes as a surprise that there is more to obtaining a patent than filling out a form and writing a check.
It's worth noting, then, that there is plenty of help out there for people who are ready to apply for a patent and would rather not hire an agent or attorney to prepare the application. I've recommended before, and will continue to recommend, David Pressman's excellent Patent it Yourself, which walks you through all of the steps in great detail. The USPTO also has a very helpful customer service line; if you need help with your application, you can call 1-800-PTO-9199, then select option 2.
And, as always, you can get in touch with me or any of the librarians at the San Francisco Public Library Government Information Center.
